Old Gunners - Various Makers

 

The decoys on this page were sold on consignment and are no longer available. In some cases I have indicated the maker or history where this info is known.

Many were handcarved by local hunters for practical gunning purposes and exhibit a rustic appearance in addition to approx. 100 years of natural patina.

The Redbreasted Merganser Drake at left was carved by a doctor in Massachusetts in the early 1900's. This one never reached the market and was sold with an offer of $4,000 from a customer who had bought many pieces of original art and other antique decoys from us over the past 10 years.

No info is available on this vintage gunner.

Appears to be homemade and as you can see, this decoy shows major shrinkage cracks and other working battle scars.

*****************************

****************************

According to the attached label, this sleeping or preening profile Canada goose was made by "Mr. Whipple" in approx. 1875 at Union Springs, near Cayuga Lake, in NY.

It is a hollow body.

See further down the page for another example from Mr. Whipple.

***************************
This decoy is a homemade carving that dates to about 1890 and was made by Dunham Tyler from the south shore of Oneida Lake.
*****************************
I have no reliable information on this old handcarved wooden crow (one of two). Has glass eyes. Dates to early 1900's. These sold on ebay in 1999 for $300.00 each. I have been told that these were carved by Charles Perdew of Illinois, however, I have no research findings that support the claim.
Below is the mate to the one above. Same maker, however, this one still has the hinged anchor rod still attached, and a bit more of the original paint.
**************************
This old vintage Golden Eye Whistler was made by Foster Parker, about 1880 - Montezuma Swamp. Note intentional angled head.
***************************
This is a late 1800's Bluebill - Evans, Hays, or Mason. We think Mason, Premier grade. Has "Fox Island" stamped on the bottom.
******************************

This is an old vintage Canvasback stamped S. Forsythe. The name is probably the owner and not the carver.

No other information is known on this one. Has a factory look to it, or it could be a very well made homemade one.

I'd like to thank Karl E. Hoekstra from Corning, NY for submitting the following info:

"Many of the design features of this decoy resemble those of H. Seymour "Putt" Smith (1878-?) from the Dresden area of Seneca Lake in New York State.

These features are the general shape of the body, the angle of the chine and forward location of the eyes.  The head is similar but not quite the same as other Smith's I have seen. It may be that this is an early Smith or an imitator from the Seneca Lake area."

Karl E. Hoekstra also submitted this decoy photo to illustrate his findings.

These newspaper articles were included:

Seymour1 | Seymour2

Thanks Karl.

*************************

All that is known about this antique Redhead gunner is from the attached label that reads: North Shore Oneida Lake.

Homemade - early 1900's.

****************************
This is an 1890's Goldeneye Whistler that according to the label was carved by Harvey Stevens and owned by a hunter from Stoney Island.
**************************

This is another example of an old hollow body gunner carved by Mr. Whipple from Cayuga Lake.

Dated 1875.

**************************

This is an early Mason Factory decoy - Detroit grade, Snakey Head.

Working touch up paint. Most of the paint is original and you can still see the combing effect.

Glass eyes. Stamped on the bottom Fox Island (owners).

**************************
Above: This is an old working gunner Bluebill from Henderson Harbor, NY. The attached tag indicates it was carved by O.M. Paddock about 1875.
**************************

Above: Old working Canvasback drake in original paint, with working touch up. I remember when I was consigned to sell this decoy. It definitely has the look and feel of an early factory decoy, being symetrical and having excellent form and proportion. My best guess was Mason, Pratt, Hayes, or Evans. Narrowed it right down, didn't I? It did have the original weight as far as I could tell under magnification. There were some numbers stamped in to the bottom, but I believe these were an inventory or previous owner's ID.

As with any of these vintage decoys, I would be interested in hearing from you if you have solid knowledge regarding the origin and/or maker.

Above: Vintage Goldeneye drake, working decoy. This Whistler suffered some significant battle damage. As you can see a big section of the bill has broken off. There are numerous shrinkage checks, has a few pellet holes, and several years of grime buildup. I tend to think this might be a Ken Harris decoy due to the shape of the metal keel - very similar, if not identical to some of the metal keels Harris used.